Ignore Ecological Light Pollution!

LPN November 2026
Is light effective at reducing crime?

LPN November 2026
Light Pollution News Podcast
Ignore Ecological Light Pollution!
Loading
/

November 2026: Ignore Ecological Light Pollution!, Light Pollution News

Do we let our feelings get ahead of us on headlight glare? And we get a little inside baseball on utility companies and lighting. Plus we have a big crime study to discuss!

Guest Lineup

Host

  • Photo of Bill McGeeney

    Bill McGeeney

Guests

  • Photo of Ari Isaak

    Ari Isaak

    EvariLABS

    Ari Isaak spent 25 years as a Geographic Information Systems (GIS) professional and came to lighting through asset management. He founded Evari Consulting in 2011, just as LED conversion was beginning, and led field operations and data management on large street lighting conversion projects including Chicago, Phoenix, San Diego, Philadelphia and Boston. Ari worked alongside lighting designers to determine which luminaire would be installed at each location. In 2024 he stepped away to start EvariLABS, which builds civil lighting design software. Its first product, EvariLUX, has run photometric calculations on ~450,000 street lights. He holds two issued U.S. patents, is a GISP and CFLC, and serves on the IES Roadway Lighting Committee.

  • Photo of Joshua Sokol

    Joshua Sokol

    Author, Freelance Journalist

    Joshua Sokol is a science journalist based in North Carolina. A contributor to The New York Times, Science, Scientific American, and other publications, his stories have been recognized by the Best American Science and Nature Writing, The Best Writing on Mathematics, the American Astronomical Society, the American Institute of Physics, and the American Geophysical Union. His upcoming popular science book The Once and Future Night: How We Loved and Lost the Stars, out April 2027 for Random House, traces the cultural and environmental history of the starry sky and makes a case for its preservation.

Summary

November Highlights

Reflect Orbital Land-based Test Casts Light Brighter Than the Full Moon

Reflect Orbital, a company developing satellite-based sunlight reflection, ran a land-based test near Lone Pine, California. A simulated light source produced illumination brighter than the full moon over an area where a search and rescue team performed simulated duties.

NHTSA to Rewrite Vehicle Headlight Glare Rules

The US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration will rewrite its vehicle lighting rules to address headlight glare. The move follows rising complaints.

Newark LED Streetlight Retrofit Cut Nighttime Violent Crime 46%, but the Effect Faded Within Two Years

A Journal of Quantitative Criminology study examined Newark, New Jersey’s 2019 to 2021 replacement of high pressure sodium streetlights with LEDs in high-crime communities. Models built on 43 million observations showed outdoor nighttime violent crime fell 46% in the first six months and assaults fell 58% in the first three months, with no displacement and no change in daytime or indoor crime. Car thefts and property crime did not decline, violent crime rose 54% in one quarter about two years after the retrofit, and the authors caution that lighting is not a silver bullet and belongs within a broader community-driven strategy.

LD+A Column “Civil Lighting Design: A Missing Discipline” Argues Streetlighting Deserves the Respect Given to Architectural Lighting

Guest Ari Isaak’s August 2026 piece in LD+A argues that lighting designers do not treat civil lighting with the same respect as architectural lighting.

Breckenridge, Colorado Reports 91% Dark Sky Lighting Compliance as Town Converts Streetlights and Faces Xcel Energy Standoff

As of October 7, the town had converted 63% of its 1,539 streetlights to top-down, two-arm Providence fixtures and hopes to finish by year’s end. The remaining 167 streetlights are owned by Xcel Energy, which has repeatedly rejected the town’s Dark Sky lighting package. Breckenridge weighs a roughly $300,000 purchase within a total upgrade cost already near $3 million.

Photographer Captures the Milky Way Over Manhattan

Jason Kurth photographed and filmed the Milky Way crossing over Manhattan from the top of Rockefeller Center using a modified monochrome camera with an 850 nanometer filter and a Kowa 8mm lens.

Texas Tech Opens Remote Observatory Access to Students, Faculty, and Staff

Students, staff, and faculty can now schedule remote imaging time at the university’s observatory in Shallowater, West Texas. Community members can use one of two new SeeStar telescopes.

Full Article List
  1. Reflect Orbital tests bright night tests catch residents off guard, CBS LA.
  2. US agency to rewrite rules to address vehicle headlight glare, David Shepardson, Reuters.
  3. Evaluating the Effect of Enhanced LED Street Lighting on Nighttime Crime in Newark, New Jersey, Journal of Quantitative Criminology.
  4. Sightlines: Civil Lighting Design: A Missing Discipline, Ari Isaak, LD+A.
  5. Breckenridge town lighting 91% compliant with Dark Sky requirements, Allison Moore, Summit Daily.
  6. As data centers expand, advocates call for regulations on lights, Héctor Alejandro Arzate, Arkansas Advocate.
  7. Photographer Captures the Milky Way Over Manhattan, Despite the Light Pollution, Matt Growcoot, PetaPixel.
  8. Texas Tech Telescope Initiative Will Open Skies For Campus Community, Doug Hensley, Texas Tech Now.

Have thoughts about today’s episode?
Why not Submit a Voicemail!
Or join our Mailing List or Substack?

Like What You See and Hear? Consider Supporting the Show.

For only the cost of one coffee each month, you can help us continue to grow. That’s $3 a month. If you like what we’re doing, if you think this adds value in any way, why not say thank you by becoming a supporter! Light Pollution News takes no outside advertising money and is 100% supported by its listeners.

Comic not generated by an artist, but we’d love if it was! If you are an artist and you wish to be featured please contact us.

Light Pollution News: November Read Along

Did any of you catch this? I’m touching on this here only because it occurred and, quite frankly, it’s a great article that loosens everyone up as we get rolling. The sunlight satellite reflection company, Reflect Orbital, did a land based test out in a place that I’ve visited a number of times, Lone Pine, California. While I didn’t find the exact place where they did it, for those of you familiar with the region, I’m going to place my bets that the test occurred south of the highest mountain in the lower 48, Mt. Whitney.

For you at home who have never been to this part of the world, the Lone Pine area is a small desert community that sits north of Death Valley, directly due east of Mt. Whitney. Just south of it, up in the Sierra Mountains, is a road that switchbacks to a lookout, and I believe this is where the Reflect Orbital folks installed their simulated light source.

The light source cast a light volume brighter than the full moon down to an area where a search and rescue team performed simulated duties.

Last year, if you at home will recall, we saw that, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, headlight glare really wasn’t much of an issue as far as accidents were concerned. Headlight glare was attributed only .1-.2% of the time in crash data spanning 2015 – 2024 for 11 states.

Despite this, the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has decided to modernize its governance of automotive illumination systems, apparently stemming from increased complaints. Those complaints came from some members of Congress, Representatives Marie Perez from Washington and Mike Thompson from California, plus from our friend Mark Baker over at the Soft Lights Foundation. Additionally, earlier this year, a AAA survey found 6 out of 10 drivers thought headlight glare was a problem and New York State representatives even tried to get the ‘BEAMS Act’ through the state legislature in 2025. The BEAMS Act would have had the New York State Department of Transportation conduct a headlight glare study. While it is currently not the regulatory standard, many automakers began early this decade to install adaptive driving headlights that are supposed to dim when oncoming vehicles are identified.

I led with that story because there’s a similarity between emotion and how we perceive problems and facts. We have a very interesting new crime study out of the Journal of Quantitative Criminology. The study tested whether brighter streetlights really do reduce crime at night. The facts on the ground are this: between 2019 and 2021, Newark, NJ swapped out high pressure sodium lighting with LEDs in high crime communities. The team hypothesized that this new brighter lighting would reduce violence and property crimes.

The study utilized three groups of utility poles to assess activity: one set included 1,419 poles that received the new LED street lights; another were 716 poles that still used high pressure sodium lighting; and there was a third 239 “catchment” poles that housed sodium street lights but sat at a closer distance from the ground. This last group was used to see if crime simply shifted when the new lights came online.

Let’s start with the good news. From 43 million observations, the team utilized models that incorporated raw data in order to try and directly tease out the impact of the light conversion. The model showed a dramatic drop of 46% in outdoor violent crimes at night during the first 6 months. Within the first three months, the model found that assaults dropped by 58% (they had also had a number for homicides, but I’m excluding that detail given that they already started with a very low N value and this would probably be one of the weakest associations they found). The crime did not simply shift around town, as the catchment areas didn’t show a significant increase in crime, nor did daytime or indoor crime change during this time period.

Now, the bad news. During this time, the model showed no reduction in car thefts and property crimes. And, perhaps most importantly, the initial ‘shock’ effect from the new lighting appears to have dissipated with time. Violent crimes rose by 54% in just one quarter, roughly two years after the lighting change (a modeled 70% increase just for assaults). Due to this, the authors warn against thinking of lighting as a ‘silver bullet’ for violent crime. Rather, they suggest that it should be part of a larger community driven plan of attack.

Ari this feeds nicely into the article that you brought up, the piece you wrote in LD+A, ‘Civil Lighting Design: A Missing Discipline.’ This was published back in August, and you argue that lighting designers don’t treat civil lighting with the same respect as architectural lighting. Why don’t you tell us a little more about why you wrote this piece and what actions you hope a reader will take.

Elsewhere, per Allison Moore at Summit Daily, back in the news is everyone’s favorite Colorado town, Breckenridge, which now is boasting that it has 91% compliant lighting in the community. Starting back in February, Breckenridge sent out 568 violation letters to property owners, with only 11 citations thus far issued.

What happens when you violate the ordinance? Well, your first citation carries a $250 fine, with a follow up penalty of $500. After strike two, the complaints are sent to a municipal judge who will determine the value of the fine as stipulated by the town’s municipal code. Property owners then have 30 – 60 days to comply, depending on what type of lighting they are.

Pertinent to our conversation today, one of the fixes that Breckenridge also had to do was update its own streetlights. As of the 7th of October, they successfully converted 63% of their 1,539 streetlights to what are called Providence fixtures. For you at home, Providence fixtures are those top down, open fixtures attached to the pole by use of two arms. It’s essentially the neighborhood friendly equivalent to traditional acorn fixtures you see out there. Breckenridge hopes to knock out the remaining lights by the end of the year.

However, there is a small subset that has an interesting story. 167 streetlights are owned by the utility company, Xcel Energy. Xcel owns the poles and fixtures, and bills the city for usage. The city reached out to work with Xcel, but Xcel repeatedly rejected the Dark Sky lighting package that the city is trying to implement.

At first glance, when you read up on this, you think, oh, that must be because Xcel is a big, evil, greedy energy company! I mean, the behavior isn’t odd. We’ve seen it with other utility companies. Hell, I see this with my own utility company. But…in this instance, that’s actually not the case!

Xcel actually has Dark Sky compliant fixtures both on their website and in operation. In this case, there is some type of specification mismatch between the two organizations. Something similar played out in Boulder, CO, whereby the town actually ended up purchasing all of the streetlights off of Xcel to the tune of $3.4M. Breckenridge is contemplating the same approach for this small subset, which they estimate will cost $300,000.

All in all, Breckenridge is sitting at a price tag of around $3M for this upgrade, maybe more pending the purchase of the Xcel Energy streetlights, should they go that route. A portion of this upgrade was necessary, I might add, and not just because they are trying to achieve a dark sky designation. There were actual maintenance costs and activities that will be resolved with the new fixture installation. The old Welsbach lights required 145 repair requests per year.

Before we get to our break this episode, I’m curious. Does anyone know why places like data centers don’t opt for motion sensing lights?

Some facilities, perhaps as required through LEED or local ordinances, are quite responsible neighbors. Others, though, don’t seem to really be too concerned. And, then, even if you do your initial build out correctly, the business may still opt for putting in glare ridden lighting to solve inadequacies of the initial build out.

So this came about due to an article that made its way up and down the Mississippi River valley, in the US. According to that article, the US has the most data centers in the world, housing server spaces for over 3,000 of them. The article interviewed Vayujeet Gokhale, a physics professor and board member for Dark Sky Missouri. Gokhale asked the question regarding data center lighting. Obviously, there are many issues on data centers that have become big ticket election items as many community residents across the country rebel against the destruction of rural farm land.

This issue of light pollution and data centers, while it may be legitimate, appears from my point of view to be invoked by people who simply don’t like data centers. Essentially, what one may call a NIMBY – not in my backyard person.

Here in the US, it was not the case in London, but in Vegas, you had the construction of the Sphere, and now in Maryland, you are about to have the construction of a second Sphere. I don’t hear the same type of pushback that you’d hear if Microsoft or Meta built a data center in town.

I came across this article from PetaPixel, by Matt Growcoot. Did you ever wish you could take a shot of the Milky Way from the city you live in? Well, I’m not going to say it’d be easy, and I’m not even going to say that it’d be feasible given building access constraints, but it appears doable.

A photographer named Jason Kurth took a stunning shot and video of the Milky Way crossing over Manhattan! Apparently, to do this, Kurth had to gain access to the top of the Rockefeller Center, whereby he used a modified monochrome camera with an 850 nanometer filter for which he appended a Kowa 8mm lens to. The rig included a cinema rod and was placed on cheese plates as tripods are banned at the Top of the Rock.

Here’s a fun one to close out today’s show.

Well, your dream may or may not be coming true. If you’re a student, staff member, or on the faculty at Texas Tech, you will now be able to schedule time to take pictures with Texas Tech’s observatory in West Texas, remotely.

The observatory, located in Shallowater, Texas, has a lot going on! It houses a 20” telescope, LX 200 Meade telescopes and milky way survey cameras. And if you’re curious what you get to use for free if you’re part of the Texas Tech community, it’s one of two new SeeStar telescopes, for which the models don’t appear to be listed but from the pictures it appears to be a SeeStar S50 and a SeeStar S30.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *